|
Post by thomas on Jan 28, 2024 18:22:22 GMT
Hard to pin point it down to any one thing, but my guess is that it was a combination, with Brexit been part of the answer, but also the growing realisation by a lot of traditional Labour voters that JC was very left wing, and there was a perception, promoted by much of the media that he was unpatriotic, a sympathiser of terrorists and a "left wing loony". Add to that was the fact that the Conservatives were now led by a populist, and not a traditional Conservative, it was all inspiring to many who would normally vote Labour. Oh do come on - you would have had to have been living in a cave for the past 4 decades to not know that Corbyn was hard left. He has never made any secret of his socialism and support for terrorists around the globe. As thomas pointed out - Corbyn (with all his baggage) did very well in 2017. 2 years later it all fell apart so it has to be down to something else rather than him personally. people like liz Kendall , Andy burnham , and all the rest were arguing vocally Corbyn was hard left in the run up to the leadership election in 2015. Im not sure why witch finder thinks this was suddenly news 4 long years later. Fuck sake his momentum goons were running around scotland during Kezia dug dales leadership between 2015 and 2017 , and she was extremely vocal in her dislike of Corbyn and his boot boys, yet he still managed to almost win the 2017 general election. These starmer supporters really do think people are fucking daft.
|
|
|
Post by Totheleft on Jan 28, 2024 18:57:27 GMT
Hard to pin point it down to any one thing, but my guess is that it was a combination, with Brexit been part of the answer, but also the growing realisation by a lot of traditional Labour voters that JC was very left wing, and there was a perception, promoted by much of the media that he was unpatriotic, a sympathiser of terrorists and a "left wing loony". Add to that was the fact that the Conservatives were now led by a populist, and not a traditional Conservative, it was all inspiring to many who would normally vote Labour. Oh do come on - you would have had to have been living in a cave for the past 4 decades to not know that Corbyn was hard left. He has never made any secret of his socialism and support for terrorists around the globe. As thomas pointed out - Corbyn (with all his baggage) did very well in 2017. 2 years later it all fell apart so it has to be down to something else rather than him personally. The Support for Corbyn dropped because the Chap hit the Fan . In May 2019, the Equality and Human Rights Commission (EHRC) launched an inquiry into whether Labour had "unlawfully discriminated against, harassed or victimised people because they are Jewish." In my opinion that was the main reason for the drop in Corbyn Support it's more than a quintessence.especially seeing it been a year since the 2016 referendum and like you said there was a Massive drop between the 2017 Ando 2019 vote.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jan 28, 2024 20:03:29 GMT
Oh do come on - you would have had to have been living in a cave for the past 4 decades to not know that Corbyn was hard left. He has never made any secret of his socialism and support for terrorists around the globe. As thomas pointed out - Corbyn (with all his baggage) did very well in 2017. 2 years later it all fell apart so it has to be down to something else rather than him personally. The Support for Corbyn dropped because the Chap hit the Fan . In May 2019, the Equality and Human Rights Commission (EHRC) launched an inquiry into whether Labour had "unlawfully discriminated against, harassed or victimised people because they are Jewish." In my opinion that was the main reason for the drop in Corbyn Support it's more than a quintessence.especially seeing it been a year since the 2016 referendum and like you said there was a Massive drop between the 2017 Ando 2019 vote. Brexit had quite a lot to do with the outcome of the 2019 election, along with the mainly Starmer driven policy of attempting to reverse it via a second referendum. In spite of which Labour still polled more votes than Blair did in 2005, and more votes in total than the Tories amongst working age people. You and many elements of the media take too seriously results without allowing for the distorting effects of FPTP. When it suits you of course.
|
|
|
Post by thomas on Jan 28, 2024 20:30:47 GMT
Oh do come on - you would have had to have been living in a cave for the past 4 decades to not know that Corbyn was hard left. He has never made any secret of his socialism and support for terrorists around the globe. As thomas pointed out - Corbyn (with all his baggage) did very well in 2017. 2 years later it all fell apart so it has to be down to something else rather than him personally. The Support for Corbyn dropped because the Chap hit the Fan . In May 2019, the Equality and Human Rights Commission (EHRC) launched an inquiry into whether Labour had "unlawfully discriminated against, harassed or victimised people because they are Jewish." In my opinion that was the main reason for the drop in Corbyn Support it's more than a quintessence.especially seeing it been a year since the 2016 referendum and like you said there was a Massive drop between the 2017 Ando 2019 vote. The claims of anti semitism within labour began almost as soon as Corbyn became leader in 2015. So the anti semitism claims , and subsequent report , which was there before Corbyn almost won in 2017 , and a report which came out ten months after he lost in 2019 , does not in any way explain labour losing 2 half million voters between the two elections Corbyn contested as leader. The puerile starmer led Brexit strategy does though. Anti-Semitism was generally not regarded as a big problem in the Labour Party before Jeremy Corbyn's election as leader in September 2015.
Under his leadership, there was an influx of new members, many of whom were vocal critics of Israel and who believed the UK, along with the US, should be tougher towards Israel, especially regarding its policies towards the Palestinians and its building of settlements in the occupied territories.
www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-45030552
Ever since his shock election to the Labour leadership in 2015, Jeremy Corbyn has been dogged by allegations of “antisemitism.
jacobin.com/2019/10/labour-party-antisemitism-claims-jeremy-corbyn
They estimate that between 1 November 2016 and 19 February 2018, while Iain McNicol was general secretary, the GLU received more than 300 complaints of antisemitism, at least half of which the report’s authors believe warranted action
www.opendemocracy.net/en/opendemocracyuk/were-labours-antisemitism-failures-really-corbyns-fault/
This also doesn't mention the high profile anti semitic claims made against naz shah , and of course ken Livingstone all prior to the 2017 general election , which Corbyn nearly won much to the blairites dismay . So to suggest all of a sudden in December 2019 that two half million voters suddenly realised there had been suggestions of anti semitism in the Labour Party and didnt vote labour accordingly is absolute blairite fucking nonsense of the highest order. The amount of claims being made in the Labour Party of anti semitism in 2017 alone prompted the party to recategorise anti semtism as hate speech and a disciplinary matter , but that didnt stop Corbyn nearly winning the election that year did it?
|
|
|
Post by thomas on Jan 28, 2024 20:41:16 GMT
The Support for Corbyn dropped because the Chap hit the Fan . In May 2019, the Equality and Human Rights Commission (EHRC) launched an inquiry into whether Labour had "unlawfully discriminated against, harassed or victimised people because they are Jewish." In my opinion that was the main reason for the drop in Corbyn Support it's more than a quintessence.especially seeing it been a year since the 2016 referendum and like you said there was a Massive drop between the 2017 Ando 2019 vote. Brexit had quite a lot to do with the outcome of the 2019 election, along with the mainly Starmer driven policy of attempting to reverse it via a second referendum. In spite of which Labour still polled more votes than Blair did in 2005, and more votes in total than the Tories amongst working age people. You and many elements of the media take too seriously results without allowing for the distorting effects of FPTP. When it suits you of course. Steve , I dont think the election will turn out as the polls suggest , and I fully expect turnout to be higher , and labour to drop ten points from where they are currently. However , regarding Brexit , which both you and I voted remain in 2016 , how do you think people are going to react if starmer gets something like 9 million three hundred thousand votes , splitting hairs here of course ,but wins a landslide on the lowest electoral turnout in uk history , and then goes onto start renegotiating with Europe or whatever other shite blairites are now describing BRINO? You talk to people , you are a politics geek , and do the rounds on these forums , as I do , and do you think 17 half million brexiters are going to sit back quietly and accept that with Farage and others screaming about starmers every move in the background? I think its a recipe for chaos and total disaster.
|
|
|
Post by thomas on Jan 28, 2024 20:50:05 GMT
The Support for Corbyn dropped because the Chap hit the Fan . In May 2019, the Equality and Human Rights Commission (EHRC) launched an inquiry into whether Labour had "unlawfully discriminated against, harassed or victimised people because they are Jewish." In my opinion that was the main reason for the drop in Corbyn Support it's more than a quintessence.especially seeing it been a year since the 2016 referendum and like you said there was a Massive drop between the 2017 Ando 2019 vote. Israel Lobby: Anti-Semitism battle in UK Labour Party 3 Jan 2017 www.aljazeera.com/news/2017/1/13/israel-lobby-anti-semitism-battle-in-uk-labour-partyanti semitism article about labour 5 months before the 2017 general election. Claims blairite party officials had been working to overthrow Corbyn since he was elected in 2015 , using anti semitism claims as a method. I mean its fucking laughable these starmer supporters re writing history.
|
|
|
Post by see2 on Jan 28, 2024 21:09:56 GMT
Oh do come on - you would have had to have been living in a cave for the past 4 decades to not know that Corbyn was hard left. He has never made any secret of his socialism and support for terrorists around the globe. As thomas pointed out - Corbyn (with all his baggage) did very well in 2017. 2 years later it all fell apart so it has to be down to something else rather than him personally. people like liz Kendall , Andy burnham , and all the rest were arguing vocally Corbyn was hard left in the run up to the leadership election in 2015. Im not sure why witch finder thinks this was suddenly news 4 long years later. Fuck sake his momentum goons were running around scotland during Kezia dug dales leadership between 2015 and 2017 , and she was extremely vocal in her dislike of Corbyn and his boot boys, yet he still managed to almost win the 2017 general election. These starmer supporters really do think people are fucking daft. 2017 was after 7 years of austerity and that was a boost wasted by hard left politics. Starmer supporters have seen the light, if hard left politics don't work lets try something that did work i.e. moderate center left politics. If it works then knockers such as yourself will have to shut up and learn the reality.
|
|
|
Post by thomas on Jan 28, 2024 21:14:23 GMT
people like liz Kendall , Andy burnham , and all the rest were arguing vocally Corbyn was hard left in the run up to the leadership election in 2015. Im not sure why witch finder thinks this was suddenly news 4 long years later. Fuck sake his momentum goons were running around scotland during Kezia dug dales leadership between 2015 and 2017 , and she was extremely vocal in her dislike of Corbyn and his boot boys, yet he still managed to almost win the 2017 general election. These starmer supporters really do think people are fucking daft. 2017 was after 7 years of austerity and that was a boost wasted by hard left politics. let me translate this latest gibber of yours. You are telling me because of austerity , Corbyn took loads votes as his hard left vision was lapped up by a flagging electorate , but not in 2019? You do realise Corbyn led both elections dont you see 2? Are you saying Corbyn went right wing in 2019?
|
|
|
Post by thomas on Jan 28, 2024 21:27:07 GMT
people like liz Kendall , Andy burnham , and all the rest were arguing vocally Corbyn was hard left in the run up to the leadership election in 2015. Im not sure why witch finder thinks this was suddenly news 4 long years later. Fuck sake his momentum goons were running around scotland during Kezia dug dales leadership between 2015 and 2017 , and she was extremely vocal in her dislike of Corbyn and his boot boys, yet he still managed to almost win the 2017 general election. These starmer supporters really do think people are fucking daft. Starmer supporters have seen the light, if hard left politics don't work lets try something that did work i.e. moderate center left politics. If it works then knockers such as yourself will have to shut up and learn the reality. I dont think I have come across anyone except you , possibly lefty , who seriously describes keir starmer as moderate centre left. I mean it's fucking hilarious you think anyone outside your blairite bubble thinks starmer centre left. You really are an old blairite dinosaur from another age aren't you see2? Here was a labour mp only last year talking about starmer labour.... A senior Labour MP claims today that Keir Starmer’s party has fallen under the control of a “rightwing, illiberal” faction that is embarking on a “witch-hunt” not only against the Corbynite left but also anyone with an independent voice www.theguardian.com/politics/2023/jul/01/rightwing-illiberal-labour-mp-jon-cruddas-condemns-keir-starmers-witch-hunt The article specifically states starmer and his bully boys expelled a 44 year centre left member of the Labour Party Neal Lawson for his centre left views.......
|
|
|
Post by see2 on Jan 28, 2024 21:32:56 GMT
anti semitism article about labour 5 months before the 2017 general election. Claims blairite party officials had been working to overthrow Corbyn since he was elected in 2015 , using anti semitism claims as a method. I mean its fucking laughable these starmer supporters re writing history. There are no such people as "blairite party officials". The reference might refer to the moderate center-Left members. Corbyn referred to Hamas and Hezbollah as "friends". Both are groups of anti-Israeli terrorists. You trying to rewrite history is "fucking laughable".
|
|
|
Post by see2 on Jan 28, 2024 21:43:25 GMT
2017 was after 7 years of austerity and that was a boost wasted by hard left politics. let me translate this latest gibber of yours. You are telling me because of austerity , Corbyn took loads votes as his hard left vision was lapped up by a flagging electorate , but not in 2019? You do realise Corbyn led both elections dont you see 2? Are you saying Corbyn went right wing in 2019? As well as Corbyn did in 2017 it still resulted in Labour polishing the opposition benches, as usual. Austerity ended in 2019, Labour had lost the weapon of austerity, and had failed to use it effectively.
|
|
|
Post by see2 on Jan 28, 2024 22:24:50 GMT
Starmer supporters have seen the light, if hard left politics don't work lets try something that did work i.e. moderate center left politics. If it works then knockers such as yourself will have to shut up and learn the reality. I dont think I have come across anyone except you , possibly lefty , who seriously describes keir starmer as moderate centre left. I mean it's fucking hilarious you think anyone outside your blairite bubble thinks starmer centre left. You really are an old blairite dinosaur from another age aren't you see2? Here was a labour mp only last year talking about starmer labour.... A senior Labour MP claims today that Keir Starmer’s party has fallen under the control of a “rightwing, illiberal” faction that is embarking on a “witch-hunt” not only against the Corbynite left but also anyone with an independent voice www.theguardian.com/politics/2023/jul/01/rightwing-illiberal-labour-mp-jon-cruddas-condemns-keir-starmers-witch-hunt The article specifically states starmer and his bully boys expelled a 44 year centre left member of the Labour Party Neal Lawson for his centre left views....... Starmer appears to be centre-Left and Blair was very very obviously center-Left, idiots like yourself are too full of crap propaganda from the right to be able to see the obvious. The hard-Left don't like Starmer, and the Conservatives fear a repeat of successive defeats in elections if Starmer are even half as successful as Blair. Neal Lawson was expelled, if he was, (he was given 14 days to explain his position, and apparently didn't) because he wanted to change the face of politics at a time when Labour were just trying to get elected after 12+ years out of office and needed all influential members pulling in the same direction. He had some good ideas, some of which, like greater cooperation with other parties, as mentioned with the Greens, could have been accommodated after Labour were in office. To do it before an election would have sent a confused message to the electorate. There were Labour members who were strongly against Corbyn, it happens in political parties that are made up of differing areas of opinion. IIRC there were some Tories who criticised Boris.
|
|
|
Post by see2 on Jan 28, 2024 22:39:43 GMT
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jan 29, 2024 1:29:40 GMT
Brexit had quite a lot to do with the outcome of the 2019 election, along with the mainly Starmer driven policy of attempting to reverse it via a second referendum. In spite of which Labour still polled more votes than Blair did in 2005, and more votes in total than the Tories amongst working age people. You and many elements of the media take too seriously results without allowing for the distorting effects of FPTP. When it suits you of course. Steve , I dont think the election will turn out as the polls suggest , and I fully expect turnout to be higher , and labour to drop ten points from where they are currently. However , regarding Brexit , which both you and I voted remain in 2016 , how do you think people are going to react if starmer gets something like 9 million three hundred thousand votes , splitting hairs here of course ,but wins a landslide on the lowest electoral turnout in uk history , and then goes onto start renegotiating with Europe or whatever other shite blairites are now describing BRINO? You talk to people , you are a politics geek , and do the rounds on these forums , as I do , and do you think 17 half million brexiters are going to sit back quietly and accept that with Farage and others screaming about starmers every move in the background? I think its a recipe for chaos and total disaster. No I do not think Brexiteers will take it lying down and I wouldn't in any case trust Starmer with anything. And I too suspect the polls will narrow as the election nears but I have few clues as to whether that will be by enough of a margin to make much difference or not. I hope so because as I have said many times my main hopes are pinned on a hung parliament. But re the Brexiteers. There are fewer of them now than there were in 2016. Heavily concentrated as they were in the older age groups, far more Brexit supporters than Remainers have simply died in the 8 years since. And polling evidence lately has been tending to show that some of those who remain have changed their minds. So the tide of opinion is running against Brexit in the long run and is unlikely to reverse unless Brexit comes to be recognised as a roaring success. At some point the New Labourites behind Starmer will seek to tie us much more closely to the EU. Most remaining Brexit supporters would never vote Labour anyway so he might feel he has more to gain than lose. But of oourse dont expect him to be honest about any of it up front unless the focus groups and media like it.
|
|
|
Post by thomas on Jan 29, 2024 7:55:06 GMT
anti semitism article about labour 5 months before the 2017 general election. Claims blairite party officials had been working to overthrow Corbyn since he was elected in 2015 , using anti semitism claims as a method. I mean its fucking laughable these starmer supporters re writing history. There are no such people as "blairite party officials". The reference might refer to the moderate center-Left members. It's not my term , I didnt invent it. It's also often used by labour politicians themselves like John cruddas and many others to refer to those on the right wing of the party.
|
|