|
Post by dappy on Jun 11, 2023 22:02:11 GMT
I already have and as I said not really the point I wanted to explore with you.
I am though interested in exploring what you consider to be the electoral prospects of a new UKIP style party lead by some combination of Farage and Johnson. How many seats could they win at the next election?
|
|
|
Post by johnofgwent on Jun 11, 2023 22:21:40 GMT
Policies are important of course Red. Labels as to exactly what is defined as right left or centre perhaps less so. Actually you could well argue that the Tories have moved significantly to the right on many matters - basically being taken over by UKIP. I relistened to Griffins Question Time appearance the other day. It was striking just how similar on so many issues his language was to the language currently being spoken by Tory Ministers and MPs. In those areas at least what was then shockingly far right has now (sadly in my view) become mainstream. But that wasn’t the point I wanted to explore with you. You evaded the question I asked. In an election in 15 months time, how many seats could a party lead by some combination of Farage and Johnson realistically win? if imay Zero to twenty odd depending entirely on how hard jeremy hunt has screwed us over snd what the alternatives are
|
|
|
Post by dappy on Jun 11, 2023 22:38:22 GMT
Thank you for at least answering the question John. You’ve given yourself a pretty big range with 0-20. I agree it would fall in that range but feel all evidence suggest we can rule out the 2-20 element of it.
And that surely is why Johnson would not be interested. We surely know that Johnson himself has no political convictions of his own merely a lust for personal political power. So why would he wish to lead a party towards virtual inevitable abject defeat and failure. Not his style surely.
Besides if the agenda here was to start a new party, surely he would have wished Dorries and the other chap to hold on to their seats and defect. Why if that is the game would they walk away now?
|
|
|
Post by Red Rackham on Jun 11, 2023 23:04:47 GMT
I already have and as I said not really the point I wanted to explore with you. I am though interested in exploring what you consider to be the electoral prospects of a new UKIP style party lead by some combination of Farage and Johnson. How many seats could they win at the next election? Mhmm, bit childish. You said the Tories have moved significantly to the right, which you must know is nonsense. You then refuse to discuss or defend your ill judged comment. Perhaps it's what we have come to expect, hey ho. As far as a new party is concerned, we are not talking about electoral success at the next election for Christs sake it takes years. It took UKIP 17 years to get from 0.3% of the vote to 13% but the the desired result was achieved. I think Labour will win the next election by far less than they expect and they may have to rely on a LibDem coalition, god help us. By the time we've had five years of a LibLab coalition, a centre right party with Boris & Farage at the helm should be a shoe in.
|
|
|
Post by johnofgwent on Jun 12, 2023 7:49:01 GMT
Thank you for at least answering the question John. You’ve given yourself a pretty big range with 0-20. I agree it would fall in that range but feel all evidence suggest we can rule out the 2-20 element of it. And that surely is why Johnson would not be interested. We surely know that Johnson himself has no political convictions of his own merely a lust for personal political power. So why would he wish to lead a party towards virtual inevitable abject defeat and failure. Not his style surely. Besides if the agenda here was to start a new party, surely he would have wished Dorries and the other chap to hold on to their seats and defect. Why if that is the game would they walk away now? I did give myself a pretty big range. I wouldn’t be so swift to rule out 90% of it. I see first hand the degree of utter vitriol in parts of the party courtesy of the new in-laws. To hand back the party cards would be utterly unthinkable (at the moment) but the last idiot who tried to conjure up some donations won’t make that mistake again while the slimy greasy dago who engineered the coup is still in the job. Not my words … In 2005 Labour activists were openly admitting shock at the degree to which Blair caused utter hatred on the doorstep. Newport East a parliamentary constituency full of ex steelworkers made ex steelworkers by Margaret Thatcher, whose Labour vote was measured not by bank tellers counting but by hotel chefs weighing out the papers on their cooking scales became an ultramarginal with a labour majority over the lib dems of barely more than 1200 In a by election not twenty miles north Blair’s replacement of a much liked and respected man with a woman non-one had heard of caused an insurrection that cost labour the safest seat in Wales, the seat that sent Nye Bevan to create the NHS and Michael Foot to lead the party into the wilderness in the Thatcher years. I was in Ebbw vale the day Peter Law addressed the town and it was beyond surreal as was the degree of hatred if the Labour party. Welsh Labour lost their one seat majority in the assembly that day and the ultramarxist plaid cymru man they gave the token presidency of the house to stop his cottage burning pals burning tbe place down had to suck a bucket of lemons and pass his casting vote to give Labour their first ministership propped up by the lib dems In truth i have absolutely no idea what the numbers might actually be. My head tells me the big fat zero is on the cards but Mhairi Black never in a million years thought she would be going to Westminster on Ed Ball’s gravy train ticket did she. It all depends on how deep the hatred goes. From what i’ve seen its pretty deep Angry people do unexpected things.
|
|
|
Post by johnofgwent on Jun 12, 2023 7:57:19 GMT
I missed something out of my last post
In the seventies Newport was a single constituency. In the eighties it split into two. Newport West was where the houses in Band D and above were, and they returned a tory in 83 whose reign was short
Newport East was the domain of a man fiercely opposed to the severn bridge tolls. On his death the seat was handed to Alan Howarth. A liar, and a bastard.
Howarth was elected a tory in Stratford.
He stabbed Major in the back and crossed the floor giving the Bard’s constituents a Labour MP for the first time.
He needed armed police protection until Blair handed him Newpirt East as a reward for his treason. The majority halved.
|
|
|
Post by dappy on Jun 12, 2023 8:53:16 GMT
I can't talk to local Welsh politics John.
What I would say to you is don't make the mistake of thinking that members of a political party are representative of potential voters for that party. Not the same thing at all as Labour found out and the Tories perhaps are about to.
I note that Red finally answered the question after many hours. Honestly I think it a little bit of a stretch to see Johnson and Farage bury their personal animosity and giant egos to work together for a couple of months. To think they are going to do so for many years seems to me utterly fanciful.
I think it is likely that Labour will form the next government although I struggle to form a view whether it will be a minority government or whether they will get a significant majority. Either way it feels inevitable that the Tories will have an almighty and probably needed fight for what exactly they want to be in the future. Have to say if I was a "populist leaning" politician currently a Tory MP, I would concentrate my energy and hopes on trying to win that impending battle and complete the UKIP takeover of the Tories rather than jumping ship to a seemingly doomed start up.
Interesting to note that you have now become a tax cutter. Not sure I had you down as that in the past. Your choice of course but have to say you seem like a GB news dream - happy to hoover up whatever propaganda they churn out. Its almost as if you were asleep for the disastrous regime of the Truss weeks when economic reality suddenly hit fanciful dogma and damaged the lives of so many British citizens. Each to their own I guess.
|
|
|
Post by Dan Dare on Jun 12, 2023 8:59:45 GMT
Cometh the hour, cometh the man - but it sure ain't Boris. Or Nige for that matter.
|
|
|
Post by dappy on Jun 12, 2023 9:55:24 GMT
Dan, I did ask you on another thread before but think you missed it.
Have you identified the man that you think will shortly cometh or is it more a hope and expectation that one day a currently unknown man will emerge
If the former, would you share who you think it is?
|
|
|
Post by Vinny on Jun 12, 2023 10:12:39 GMT
Cometh the hour, cometh the man - but it sure ain't Boris. Or Nige for that matter. And you didn't expect us to vote to leave the EU. I don't know what the long term future holds, but, I was right about leaving the EU. I'm so glad we have. Boris and Nigel both helped make that happen.
|
|
|
Post by Dan Dare on Jun 12, 2023 10:21:40 GMT
Something I suspect the GBP will never thank them for when it realises what a crock of shit Brexit has turned out to be. Which I believe it already has, except for die-hard fundamentalists.
My current prediction is an application to rejoin before 2030, perhaps even as soon as 2025. The next election could well be fought on this question. If not the next, then certainly the one after.
|
|
|
Post by patman post on Jun 12, 2023 11:21:04 GMT
Something I suspect the GBP will never thank them for when it realises what a crock of shit Brexit has turned out to be. Which I believe it already has, except for die-hard fundamentalists. My current prediction is an application to rejoin before 2030, perhaps even as soon as 2025. The next election could well be fought on this question. If not the next, then certainly the one after. So can we expect another decade of bitter political campaigning and fighting (often about lies and myths) again involving the whole population — or has that all been used up…?
|
|
|
Post by Dan Dare on Jun 12, 2023 11:27:56 GMT
I'm sensing that the more commited fundamentalists have retired from the fray or are keeping a low profile so, hopefully, any future debate will be more civil than the last time.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jun 12, 2023 13:15:47 GMT
In an election in 15 months time, how many seats could a party lead by some combination of Farage and Johnson realistically win? How did it go when the Brexit Party had less time to form up and stand in the final vote of ours in the EU elections? (They won)
|
|
|
Post by dappy on Jun 12, 2023 13:44:54 GMT
Trying to find out what those likely to be sympathetic to a new party led by Johnson and/or Farage would expect their performance to be at the next election was the point of asking the question. Do I take it from your reply that you think there is a realistic chance of them winning say 200 seats?
|
|