ginnyg2
Full Member
Don't blame me - I voted for someone else.
Posts: 414
|
Post by ginnyg2 on Jun 5, 2024 9:54:10 GMT
As no thread on this maybe like us you're all bored already.
|
|
|
Post by Fairsociety on Jun 5, 2024 10:01:17 GMT
Think we are all done with empty gestures, that applies to both Sunak and Starmer.
|
|
|
Post by andrewbrown on Jun 5, 2024 10:17:13 GMT
It was pretty awful to be honest. They both made me cringe.
I think that the highlight for me was Sunak saying boat crossings going up where actually coming down. The audience just laughed at him.
But Starmer didn't sell Labour either. Too busy with the "I'm not a Tory" but didn't really have an alternative vision.
I think they need to get their manifestos out so that we can see their policies.
|
|
|
Post by dodgydave on Jun 5, 2024 10:29:36 GMT
Blair sold a positive vision in 1997. Starmer is just peddling populist lies to win at all costs. Worst of all, the idiot has totally boxed himself into a corner by going on about high taxes so won't be able to do anything of value when he wins.
Sunak is trapped by the right of his party, and has to keep peddling utter garbage policies like Rwanda.
Personally, I think both "could" be decent PM's, but they are surrounded by talentless idiots who force them into stupid positions.
Quite depressing really.
|
|
|
Post by see2 on Jun 6, 2024 7:31:57 GMT
It was pretty awful to be honest. They both made me cringe. I think that the highlight for me was Sunak saying boat crossings going up where actually coming down. The audience just laughed at him. But Starmer didn't sell Labour either. Too busy with the "I'm not a Tory" but didn't really have an alternative vision. I think they need to get their manifestos out so that we can see their policies. And the claim that NHS waiting lists are coming down when the mountainous increase in waiting lists that took place under Sunak, had just the tip of that mountain nipped.
|
|
|
Post by witchfinder on Jun 6, 2024 10:16:41 GMT
According to the mainstream media, the electorate are scared to death of tax rises, but in reality is this really true. ?
How the hell can we have any hope in hell of repairing the damage to the NHS and other public services without any money to do it. It seems ( according to the media ) that Joe Public want first class public services, and tax cuts, we cannot have both.
In previous general elections the Lib Dems made it a policy aim to increase income tax by a penny, and spend it on our NHS, and they increased their votes and seats, this is called .... HONESTY.
Obviously no one wants to be taxed to Kingdom Come, but I am sure that if one of the big parties told it straight to the electorate "we want to raise income tax by a penny to help repair our NHS", I think it would be a vote winner.
BOTH political parties are not coming clean, especially the Tories who vow to cut tax no matter what.
However - the truth might yet come out when the manifestoes are published, with Labours set of plans expected on 13th June.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jun 6, 2024 17:43:05 GMT
A 1p increase in the tax rate would create an extra £5.5 billion for the treasury This is about 3% of the current NHS spending, so decisions would have to be carefully made to target areas which would improve service to patients.
|
|
|
Post by ratcliff on Jun 6, 2024 17:46:10 GMT
A 1p increase in the tax rate would create an extra £5.5 billion for the treasury This is about 3% of the current NHS spending, so decisions would have to be carefully made to target areas which would improve service to patients. They'd hire even more diversity managers and staff to wander around corridors holding clipboards trying to look self important
|
|
|
Post by Pacifico on Jun 6, 2024 21:07:00 GMT
BOTH political parties are not coming clean, especially the Tories who vow to cut tax no matter what. Oh fuck off - have you not learn't by now?. The Tories have spent every election since 2010 vowing to cut taxes - and yet here we are with record levels of taxation.. Taxes are going only one way whatever party is in power - and that is up. There is no difference between either of them.
|
|
|
Post by dodgydave on Jun 7, 2024 2:36:11 GMT
According to the mainstream media, the electorate are scared to death of tax rises, but in reality is this really true. ? How the hell can we have any hope in hell of repairing the damage to the NHS and other public services without any money to do it. It seems ( according to the media ) that Joe Public want first class public services, and tax cuts, we cannot have both. In previous general elections the Lib Dems made it a policy aim to increase income tax by a penny, and spend it on our NHS, and they increased their votes and seats, this is called .... HONESTY. Obviously no one wants to be taxed to Kingdom Come, but I am sure that if one of the big parties told it straight to the electorate "we want to raise income tax by a penny to help repair our NHS", I think it would be a vote winner. BOTH political parties are not coming clean, especially the Tories who vow to cut tax no matter what. However - the truth might yet come out when the manifestoes are published, with Labours set of plans expected on 13th June. This is what pisses me off about Labour. They have spent the last two years telling us how high taxes are, which is quite frankly bollocks as we pay far less than most other Western countries. Now we are going to have a Labour government that can't do shit for 5 years. Before anybody mentions it, we aren't growing our way out of this either. The "growth" under New Labour was not real growth, it was a rapid increase in retail spending... funded by an explosion of consumer debt... hence we got fucked so badly during the financial crisis! We need to find some grown up politicians, who will address the obvious, we are living way beyond our means so its either more austerity or raises taxes.
|
|
|
Post by see2 on Jun 7, 2024 5:55:47 GMT
BOTH political parties are not coming clean, especially the Tories who vow to cut tax no matter what. Oh fuck off - have you not learn't by now?. The Tories have spent every election since 2010 vowing to cut taxes - and yet here we are with record levels of taxation.. Taxes are going only one way whatever party is in power - and that is up. There is no difference between either of them. The Tories look outwards in an attempt to entice wealth into the country, Starmer is seeking to create wealth from inside the country. A major difference between the parties.
|
|
|
Post by johnofgwent on Jun 7, 2024 6:06:07 GMT
Oh fuck off - have you not learn't by now?. The Tories have spent every election since 2010 vowing to cut taxes - and yet here we are with record levels of taxation.. Taxes are going only one way whatever party is in power - and that is up. There is no difference between either of them. The Tories look outwards in an attempt to entice wealth into the country, Starmer is seeking to create wealth from inside the country. A major difference between the parties. Labour don't know how to create wealth end of. And no, I didn't watch it. Why the fuck would I bother
|
|
|
Post by johnofgwent on Jun 7, 2024 6:17:23 GMT
BOTH political parties are not coming clean, especially the Tories who vow to cut tax no matter what. Oh fuck off - have you not learn't by now?. The Tories have spent every election since 2010 vowing to cut taxes - and yet here we are with record levels of taxation.. Taxes are going only one way whatever party is in power - and that is up. There is no difference between either of them. I found this site quite interesting, although I wouldn't put much faith in anything the OBR says quoted there. What's REALLY interesting is the spending adjusted to 1995 prices of government from 1900 to 2019. Any illusion the Tories ever pushed back the boundaries of the state interference with our lives is truly squashed. Interesting that all the graphs before that one cover the COVID spending. This one doesn't. Tells you an awful lot about statistics as a propaganda and manipulation tool that www.economicshelp.org/blog/5326/economics/government-spending/
|
|
|
Post by see2 on Jun 7, 2024 6:18:17 GMT
According to the mainstream media, the electorate are scared to death of tax rises, but in reality is this really true. ? How the hell can we have any hope in hell of repairing the damage to the NHS and other public services without any money to do it. It seems ( according to the media ) that Joe Public want first class public services, and tax cuts, we cannot have both. In previous general elections the Lib Dems made it a policy aim to increase income tax by a penny, and spend it on our NHS, and they increased their votes and seats, this is called .... HONESTY. Obviously no one wants to be taxed to Kingdom Come, but I am sure that if one of the big parties told it straight to the electorate "we want to raise income tax by a penny to help repair our NHS", I think it would be a vote winner. BOTH political parties are not coming clean, especially the Tories who vow to cut tax no matter what. However - the truth might yet come out when the manifestoes are published, with Labours set of plans expected on 13th June. This is what pisses me off about Labour. They have spent the last two years telling us how high taxes are, which is quite frankly bollocks as we pay far less than most other Western countries.Now we are going to have a Labour government that can't do shit for 5 years. Before anybody mentions it, we aren't growing our way out of this either. The "growth" under New Labour was not real growth, it was a rapid increase in retail spending... funded by an explosion of consumer debt... hence we got fucked so badly during the financial crisis! We need to find some grown up politicians, who will address the obvious, we are living way beyond our means so its either more austerity or raises taxes. Nonsense, the country is highly taxed in UK terms. You are just doing your usual, throwing more shit at Labour. More shit thrown at Labour, a less biased individual would wait and see. The growth under New Labour was seen in an expanding economy. Consumer debt was mostly increases in mortgages. Extra borrowing was made available because the Banks thought they had found a way to increase their wealth, which eventually proved to be totally wrong. The UK got "fucked" so badly by the 'I F Meltdown' because Thatcher destroyed so much of our internal wealth creation by destroying thousands of UK businesses, and adding millions to the unemployed, which left the New Labour with little option but to rely on Financial Services, which initially appeared to be an excellent decision. Educating the electorate to be not so easily led and so easily biased (as in giving Thatcher 11 years as PM) would be an excellent improvement. It could begin with posters like yourself being far less biased and much more objective.
|
|
|
Post by Pacifico on Jun 7, 2024 6:18:41 GMT
Oh fuck off - have you not learn't by now?. The Tories have spent every election since 2010 vowing to cut taxes - and yet here we are with record levels of taxation.. Taxes are going only one way whatever party is in power - and that is up. There is no difference between either of them. The Tories look outwards in an attempt to entice wealth into the country, Starmer is seeking to create wealth from inside the country. A major difference between the parties. Higher taxes do not create wealth - if it did then Europe would not be the slowest growing continent on the planet.
|
|