|
Post by The Squeezed Middle on May 15, 2023 18:49:36 GMT
...Sometimes you almost think like your average sociopath. I bow to your superior knowledge of the average sociopath, since you're so very average in everything else I already assumed that it extended to your sociopathy. Just as well.
|
|
|
Post by The Squeezed Middle on May 15, 2023 18:51:03 GMT
It was never my idea to charge people large sums for voting. I did suggest you do so if you think others should, but of course you wont. You floated it, I just ran with it. Hoist, yet again, by your own petard.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on May 15, 2023 19:05:30 GMT
It was never my idea to charge people large sums for voting. I did suggest you do so if you think others should, but of course you wont. You floated it, I just ran with it. Hoist, yet again, by your own petard. "my proposal would restrict voting to those who actually finance society...." Your exact words. So if it were my idea do you think I am inserting my thoughts into your head? Time to get the tin foil hat out. lol Of course it was never my idea. I opposed the idea of anyone having to pay to vote from the very start. You seized upon it as a good idea . You are just doing what you always do when you have lost the argument and made yourself look a knob. Try and twist and distort, blame your own stupid ideas on the ones criticising them and blatantly trolling. Total clown mode in other words whose mission is no longer intelligent debate cos you lost that one so now trying to provoke and wind up, the only kind of victory you have left which you hope to achieve. Quite pathetic really. I therefore will not respond to you further unless you say something honestly factual or intelligent. Accusing me of championing what I have opposed from the beginning and such like stupidities just wont cut it.
|
|
|
Post by Bentley on May 15, 2023 19:05:39 GMT
Your whole argument is based on your own claim about how other people would react to paying £1400 to vote . Its all been constructed between your ears and your ears have been listening to your shoulder chip. Only adult UK citizens should be able to vote . People born within the criteria to be given UK citizenship at birth are lucky . The rest should acquire UK citizenship by the proper channels and pay the appropriate cost. Double standards. UK residents such as yourself should get the vote for free, but UK residents born elsewhere should have to pay for the privilege? Well I disagree. I think residency here, committing to this country by living and working here, paying eligible UK taxes whilst here, using UK services here, contributing to the nation whilst here should confer the right to vote without having to pay a fortune to do so. That you think otherwise suggests a distrust of Johnny Foreigner of a rathe primitive kind, an excessive exaltation of the idea if citizenship, and a fear that they might vote in what you regard as the wrong way. As such you will never persuade me when you are so transparent. It’s not double standards you moron. Everyone becomes a citizen of the country that they fit the criteria. Its when you want to become a citizen of another country that you need to make an effort. In your fantasy world I should be able to become a citizen of any country in the world if I felt like it . You post such crap , it’s embarrassing.
|
|
|
Post by buccaneer on May 15, 2023 19:09:38 GMT
Well, at least you admit you have no substance to offer in this discussion then. Glad you cleared that up for us. All you have is the fear of extending the francjhise in case they disagree with you at the ballot box. This is not logically or morally compelling. You see, I don't actually care how they vote. I just want them to have the right to do so because it seems only reasonable to do so. Nope. The voting system for non-citizens isn't broken, therefore it doesn't need fixing. That's the point.
|
|
|
Post by buccaneer on May 15, 2023 19:13:06 GMT
So what's the problem then in them getting citizenship? Oh, that's right Starmer would rather rush through perm residents, and allow them to vote in order to consolidate a pro-Labour/pro-EU demographic. Er, this has to be the most wilfully obtuse comment of the year thus far. The very post you are quoting explains the problem in them getting citizenship, namely the huge cost. OMG how more clearly does that inconvenient fact have to be spelt out? Now this is obtuse. Par for the course. So, these taxpaying committed workers have to save a little in order to get their citizenship. Christ what next, handing out free cars for them to drive as well.
|
|
|
Post by buccaneer on May 15, 2023 19:15:32 GMT
What, for the right to vote? over £1400? What fecking planet are you on.!!! That money is revenue for the government you moron. I thought a paid up socialist would agree with that notion. No wonder Corbyn and the rest of rent a mob who demand everything for nothing never got elected.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on May 15, 2023 19:21:36 GMT
Double standards. UK residents such as yourself should get the vote for free, but UK residents born elsewhere should have to pay for the privilege? Well I disagree. I think residency here, committing to this country by living and working here, paying eligible UK taxes whilst here, using UK services here, contributing to the nation whilst here should confer the right to vote without having to pay a fortune to do so. That you think otherwise suggests a distrust of Johnny Foreigner of a rathe primitive kind, an excessive exaltation of the idea if citizenship, and a fear that they might vote in what you regard as the wrong way. As such you will never persuade me when you are so transparent. It’s not double standards you moron. Everyone becomes a citizen of the country that they fit the criteria. Its when you want to become a citizen of another country that you need to make an effort. In your fantasy world I should be able to become a citizen of any country in the world if I felt like it . You post such crap , it’s embarrassing. You are clearly too stupid to understand what I have been saying so prefer to indulge in name calling. I have not said anyone should be able to become a citizen anywhere they like. You just invented that straw man to have something you could understand to attack. What I said was that residency for a certain period of time should be enough to earn the right to vote without needing to shell out for the costs of citizenship - as it already does for EU and Commonwealth nationals in local elections. I do not think that is unreasonable. You do, so there we are. I am not going to cry about it. If you want Johnny Foreigner to have to jump through countless hoops and shell out a fortune to achieve what you obviously regard as the exalted status of British citizenship just to be able to vote in the nation he lives and works in thats up to you. I don't agree. I think if you have committed to this country and live here and contribute here you should have a vote here. I do not think that idea is rocket science nor in any way outrageous. You are just afraid they won't vote your way so want to keep as many of them away from the ballot box as possible. And you are hiding behind the fig leaf of citizenship as the only possible cloak of principle you can find.
|
|
|
Post by Bentley on May 15, 2023 19:25:53 GMT
It’s not double standards you moron. Everyone becomes a citizen of the country that they fit the criteria. Its when you want to become a citizen of another country that you need to make an effort. In your fantasy world I should be able to become a citizen of any country in the world if I felt like it . You post such crap , it’s embarrassing. You are clearly too stupid to understand what I have been saying so prefer to indulge in name calling. I have not said anyone should be able to become a citizen anywhere they like. You just invented that straw man to have something you could understand to attack. What I said was that residency for a certain period of time should be enough to earn the right to vote without needing to shell out for the costs of citizenship - as it already does for EU and Commonwealth nationals in local elections. I do not think that is unreasonable. You do, so there we are. I am not going to cry about it. If you want Johnny Foreigner to have to jump through countless hoops and shell out a fortune to achieve what you obviously regard as the exalted status of British citizenship just to be able to vote in the nation he lives and works in thats up to you. I don't agree. I think if you have committed to this country and live here and contribute here you should have a vote here. I do not think that idea is rocket science nor in any way outrageous. You are just afraid they won't vote your way so want to keep as many of them away from the ballot box as possible. And you are hiding behind the fig leaf of citizenship as the only possible cloak of principle you can find. “I have not said anyone should be able to become a citizen anywhere they like“ That seems to be the logical conclusion to your past waffle. I got bored after the first sentence . Trying to get sense out of Mr Angry is too boring to be worth trying .
|
|
|
Post by The Squeezed Middle on May 15, 2023 19:27:46 GMT
"my proposal would restrict voting to those who actually finance society...." Your exact words. So if it were my idea do you think I am inserting my thoughts into your head? Ahem, your exact words, to which I was responding: ...would you pay £1400 for the right to vote?... To which I said "Yes". Time to get the tin foil hat out. lol I think you just did. Of course it was never my idea. I opposed the idea of anyone... Yadda, yadda. I couldn't give a monkeys. You, albeit inadvertently, raised an interesting point for once and I ran with it. Congratulations. Of course I don't credit you with it because you clearly don't realise the significance of the point that you raised. Which is why you're getting angry now. But that's OK, because that's just what dim people do. Well, along with voting lefty... Now, do one. You're boring me.
|
|
|
Post by buccaneer on May 15, 2023 19:28:35 GMT
Oh stop blubbing, if you wanted to be able to vote in the United States of America you'd have to take out citizenship, if you wanted to vote in Norway you'd have to take out citizenship. And you'd have to pay for it. This is how the real world works. Stop complaining that we are doing what everyone else does. Bollocks. If I think giving the vote to all who live and work here after a certain period of residency that is my right. And I am not simply complaining in the wilderness. I am supporting proposals actually being put forward by the leader of a political party, which is why the subject is even under discussion and why the usual suspects including you have decided to indulge in a whinge fest because you fear anyone newly franchised might not vote as you want. And I dont give a flying fuck what anyone else does. I want to do right by all the people living and working here regardless of nationality. And do you know what? You and others of your dubious ilk in this thread are coming closer than the Labour supporters like see 2 ever have in making me consider a vote for Labour. Because your contempt makes me want to elect someone who will ram it down your obnoxious throats. You have spent the last year or so decrying Starmer and Blue Labour. Now he is considering the political engineering of a sinister move to all non-citizens by giving them the right to vote, you U-turn like he does and consider voting Blue Labour. That's the conviction of a Blairite if I ever saw it - to 'ram it down our obnoxious throats' is the same as 'rubbing the right's nose in diversity' when Blair flooded Britain with non-convergent eastern bloc migrants. Shame on you.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on May 15, 2023 19:34:14 GMT
All you have is the fear of extending the francjhise in case they disagree with you at the ballot box. This is not logically or morally compelling. You see, I don't actually care how they vote. I just want them to have the right to do so because it seems only reasonable to do so. Nope. The voting system for non-citizens isn't broken, therefore it doesn't need fixing. That's the point. I disagree. I think people who live and work and contribute here and have made this country their home should have to right to vote after a certain period without having to pay a fortune to become a citizen. That is my point and where we fundamentally disagree. I also have a suspicion that many on your side of the argument are motivated by suspicions that these nationals might not vote how you'd like them to. I think it is only fair to give people living and working here, paying our taxes, using our services, obeying our laws, the right to a say in those taxes, services, and laws just like you and I. I fail to see the moral objection to that but can all too easily see the barely disguised partisan political objections. I have for instance already clocked that everyone who has posted in this thread on your side of the argument just happens to be a right winger, or an avid Brexiteer, or both. So your fears are blatantly obvious. That the foreign nationals resident here might be too left leaning or too pro-EU or both. Most of the ones I have ever know are go getter types more likely to lean to the right, so I think you are actually wrong on the left versus right score. EU nationals might well be more pro-EU than you'd like but non EU foreign nationals have no reason to be
|
|
|
Post by Vinny on May 15, 2023 19:51:12 GMT
Starmer's policy will not go down well, it may cost him the next election.
Btw Srb, how can you be left leaning AND pro EU? The EU is an extreme capitalist race to the bottom maintaining low wages in Eastern Europe instead of seeking to bring about economic parity with tax and wage harmonisation.
The EU is RIGHT WING. Extreme right wing at that. Economic Darwinism.
If that's what you support, then you're actually an extreme right winger in denial.
Any legal immigrant is welcome to apply for British citizenship. So long as they fulfil the criteria and pay the fee, they become one of us. If they've a serious criminal record, they can fuck off when they first try to apply for a visa, but if they're law abiding, and they contribute? Welcome to Britain.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on May 15, 2023 19:53:13 GMT
...would you pay £1400 for the right to vote?... To which I said "Yes". As so often I was attempting to expose a double standard by positing the notion that you expect others to pay a large sum to vote when you wouldnt yourself. You tried to dodge that by putting your foot in it in your claim that you would happily pay such a sum to vote and think everyone else should too. So the notion of everyone having to pay a large sum to vote was clearly yours which you actually admitted to, calling it your proposal. Of course when confronted with the reality that no one would ever win an election with such a stupid commitment, the utterly stupid position you had argued yourself into in an attempt to avoid the charge of double standards became painfully apparent, even to yourself. Hence the descent into trolling and the ridiculous attempt to portray the notion as my idea. This was accompanied by your trademark attempt at wind ups and goads, followed inevitably when that did not suffice, with your inevitable flouncing off, citing boredom. This is your usual modus operandi when argued into a position where you are made to look a fool. You have done this before and I am very familiar with such behaviour from you. I have seen you do the same thing to others who better you as well. It always follows the same pattern every time someone sticks the course for long enough and succeeds in trapping you into a silly argument that you lack the humility to climb down from. Enough said.
|
|
|
Post by Vinny on May 15, 2023 20:06:55 GMT
If I were moving to another country and wanted to vote in it, I would pay whatever fee they asked of me. If it required me to save up, I would save up. £1400 is not a lot of cash.
The average annual wage is over £26 thousand. £23.33 into a savings account for 5 years covers the fee. £46.66 into a savings account for 2.5 years covers the fee.
It is not difficult if there is the determination there, to put money aside and earn the citizenship.
The PC I am talking to you from cost me over £1k. I didn't buy it in one go, I bought bits one month at a time. It has 32gb ram and 8gb of graphics, the processor alone was over £200. The graphics card was over £500. The power supply is the best part of £150.
I put money aside and bought parts piece by piece until I had what I needed. And then I put it all together.
It took me a whole evening, but it was worth it.
Have you never saved up for anything, or paid in installments for anything?
|
|